Blogging is Dead (Again)

Chris Cagle has a new blog post that addresses what seems to be a decline in blogging in the field of film studies. Chris grounds this observation in the context of his own essay in Jason Sperb and Scott Balcerzak’s edited collection, Cinephilia in the Age of Digital Reproduction, Vol. 2, in which Chris offers a polemical argument endorsing the potential benefits of academic blogging for film scholars. Like Chris, I find that the initial energy behind academic film blogging seems to have waned–even as my own output has declined dramatically–and I think it’s worth asking about why that is happening. I have a couple of answers in mind and would be curious to know if others have similar experiences:

First, blogging has lost its novelty factor. Blogging appealed for early adapters and now we’ve moved on to other forms of networked communication–Twitter, Facebook, mashups, image macros–that make the practices of blogging feel less vital and immediate. There are so many competing communication formats, blogs are just one place where we can devote our limited energy.

On a related note, film scholars may be deciding that the energy needed to maintain a blog isn’t worth the payoff. I’d imagine that most tenure committees still don’t give significant credit to a well-maintained academic blog. I barely mention mine in my tenure file, even if it (indirectly at least) had a profound effect on how I was able to build a scholarly network. But on an anecdotal level, blogging feels like the one thing I can sacrifice while trying to publish, teach, grade, do service, and maintain a healthy family life. Short and fast–again, think Twitter and Facebook–is easier, even if it is more difficult to archive.

Similarly, TV lends itself to water-cooler discussion. Even if large numbers of TV fans can use DVRs and other tools for catch-up viewing, there is a premium on watching live and sharing in the reactions to narratives as they unfold. While film premieres have a similar value–there is obviously some pleasure in being the first to see and review a movie–the fragmentation of the theatrical distribution schedule has made it harder to sustain the conversations that many independent films inspire. Even if VOD allows for somewhat more simultaneous distribution schedules, most of us aren’t watching movies that way.

Finally, I wonder if it’s the movies themselves that are the problem (or, more precisely, if it’s our perception of the movie industry). Chris is perhaps the best example out there of a scholar who uses his blog to explore film history, but blogs seem best suited to looking at the contemporary, the immediate, and as a number of non-academic film critics have asserted, there may be reasons to be pessimistic about the current state of the film industry. Richard Brody of The New Yorker is more subtle here than David Denby or David Thompson, who both seem to have concluded that cinema is declining or dead. But there seems to be an on-going and inescapable sentiment that movies have lost their cultural relevance.

There are probably other factors here. Some of this could be purely a personal perception. I’d also be curious to see if academic TV bloggers feel as if the initial energy associated with blogging has faded. Like Chris, I don’t think that these forms of networked scholarly communication are dying so much as they are transforming. And I still see more dialogue between entertainment journalists and media scholars, but like Chris, I’m curious to see what forms this dialogue will take.

Update: I think the cinetrix has probably the best possible response to the current round of hand-wringing about the decline of film blogging. I’ll be the first to admit that some of what I was describing is probably personal, and some of it may be specific to academic writers (although even there, I realize that a number of media scholars continue to blog frequently and continue to offer a wide array of approaches to blogging).

2 Comments »

  1. Derek Kompare Said,

    September 29, 2012 @ 10:19 am

    I’m not an ideal example by any stretch, as my blogging has been the very definition of “sporadic,” averaging about six posts a year. Blogging has been, like so many other endeavors in the past decade or so, one of those things that we all should do, and that we feel we’re losing out if we’re not. It’s the obligatory part of it that I resent. As you said, the novelty is gone, and increasingly it feels like yet another task on top of everything else we’re supposed to do. And yet it keeps beckoning. I know I feel guilty every time I go to my blog and see it hasn’t had a new post since (gulp) February! Yet I also know I’ve hardly been slouching in every other regard in that time as well.

    I also agree that at this point, a fairly active presence on Twitter is arguably more valuable than a reliably updated blog. As long as your thoughts get out there, and you’re using other modes for longer form expression (albeit more irregularly), than I think occasional blogging or even not blogging is OK. Besides, there are, in fact, way too many blogs (and many of them fantastic, though many of them jumping in on too many of the same topics of the moment) to keep up with on an ongoing basis. It honestly wouldn’t hurt anything to for the pace to slow down a bit across the board. I’d rather read three or five occasional film/media blogs on disparate issues than a dozen or more regularly updated ones covering the latest releases and news events.

  2. Chuck Said,

    September 29, 2012 @ 10:27 am

    Good points, Derek. Some of this may be self-reflection posing as wider analysis, and I think you’re right that occasional substantive academic blog posts may carry more weight than frequent posts that focus just on being timely. There are certainly examples of academic blogs that answer this need for immediacy–Chris Becker and Catherine Grant’s blogs come to mind. I also feel that sense of obligation, although it’s unclear where this sense of obligation comes from, at least for me.

    I do think Twitter can supplement and even substitute for what used to happen on blogs. Perhaps what I am most lamenting is the feeling that I don’t have time to read and watch and keep up with everything that’s out there.

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment

Subscribe without commenting